The Premiership Overated X1

johnnytodd

Well-Known Member
Messages
5,273
Likes
1,031
Location
Cheshire
Supports
Everton
Thread starter #1
1. Mingolet
2. Walker
3. Shawcross
4. Mertishacker
5. Shaw
6. Barkley
7. Horrenderson
8. Walcotts
9. Wiltshire
10. Bony
11. Falcao

underated X1 coming soon
 
Messages
2,564
Likes
646
Location
Didcot
Supports
Jack Wilshere
#2
Nobody rates Walker though? No place on this list for him.

I can't be bothered with a full 11 just yet, here are a few mentions though...

  1. Krul
  2. Shaw
  3. Mirallas
  4. Blind
  5. Coutinho
  6. Lukaku
  7. Fellaini
  8. Delph
  9. Henderson (Horrenderson :lol:)
 

Bottega Don

Lenging Man Down
Messages
3,269
Likes
1,160
Supports
Scunthorpe United
#3
Considering how criticized Mingolet has been this season I wouldn't say he's overrated, he had a bad spell at the start of the season but he's been great for a while now. He's more underrated with the amount of criticism he received.
 

Toffee_Joe

Active Member
Messages
180
Likes
30
Supports
Everton
#4
Something like

Hart
(struggling for a right back)
Kompany
Lescott
Shaw
Walcott
Henderson
Delph
Sterling
RVP
Benteke
 

Cardsfan

Well-Known Member
Messages
3,106
Likes
875
Supports
Woking
#5
Who rates Falcao anymore? And on a different level I'm not really sure how "rated" Shawcross is. Here's my effort -

Courtois
(Not sure on RB) Mertesacker Kompany Shaw
Jesus Navas Blind Barkley (not sure on LM)
Rooney Benteke
 
Last edited:

BlueBee

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,183
Likes
282
Supports
Making goonerz cry
#7
Courtois too?

He's made a couple of clangers this season but he's made up for them with some ridiculous saves. His triple save at Hull Tigers was unbelievable.

Krul is an overrated keeper.
 
Messages
63
Likes
25
Supports
Peterborough United F.C.
#10
Krul
Shaw
Mertesacker
Cahill
Zabaleta
Sterling
Henderson
Blind
DiMaria
Lukakau
Costa (even Kane has more goals)
 

BlueBee

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,183
Likes
282
Supports
Making goonerz cry
#11
Krul
Shaw
Mertesacker
Cahill
Zabaleta
Sterling
Henderson
Blind
DiMaria
Lukakau
Costa (even Kane has more goals)
C'mon mate, if you want to pull off the Adrian Durham you're going to have to add some more Arsenal players.
 

Stevencc

Site Supporter
Site Supporter
Messages
13,242
Likes
7,218
Location
°
Supports
°
#15
I'm surprised to see Henderson on so many lists. He's only just starting to get the credit he deserves.
 
Last edited:
Messages
417
Likes
180
Supports
Neutral
#16
Wow. There are some right suggestions on this thread.

Courtois, Bony, Hart, Rooney & Cazorla will take some beating as outragous suggestions.

I'd pick bones with Jesus Navas (overrated? He seems maligned mostly and is having a good season) as well.

Otherwise, surprised to Henderson in there, steadily becoming a very good player, but he is still hyped massively so I can understand it a bit moer.
 
Messages
2,564
Likes
646
Location
Didcot
Supports
Jack Wilshere
#19
Juve are interested apparently. If we can get 40mil for him I'd be happy to see him go. Not sure who'd I'd like to replace him though.
Looks like you hit the '4' key by mistake there.


EDIT: Actually his contract runs until 2019 so you might get away with that at a push, Juve don't have that kind of money though, or they didn't a couple of seasons ago as they couldn't pay transfer fees upfront.
 

G.B

Well-Known Member
Messages
3,204
Likes
2,097
Supports
Newcastle United
#23
De Gea

Ivanovic
Cahill
Kompany
Azpilicueta

Henderson
Herrera
Hazard
Sterling

Rooney
Benteke
 

Stevencc

Site Supporter
Site Supporter
Messages
13,242
Likes
7,218
Location
°
Supports
°
#25
Hey, G.B - Whitechapel, BlueBee and AdrianDurham said Krul. What do you think of that?
 

G.B

Well-Known Member
Messages
3,204
Likes
2,097
Supports
Newcastle United
#27
Hey, G.B - Whitechapel, BlueBee and AdrianDurham said Krul. What do you think of that?
I think they've been memebrs of the forum(s) for a long time and each of them has displayed a complete lack of understanding about the game of football on numerous occasions during this time, and therefore I see little reason to explain to them why they are wrong, as they simply wouldn't be able to comprehend my words.

Edit: Apart from Durham, but he's like on the radio n that.

I like how you've kept in with the wumming spirit of the thread.
2muchliverpool4um8?
 

BlueBee

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,183
Likes
282
Supports
Making goonerz cry
#29
Hey, G.B - Whitechapel, BlueBee and AdrianDurham said Krul. What do you think of that?
I think De Gea is overrated. He's a good keeper but lots of his saves are quite standard.

Lloris and Courtois are both better.
 

Forum statistics

Threads
14,938
Messages
923,701
Members
5,090
Latest member
Bordon Shot

Latest posts