No one said he would be?
I don't understand even the principle behond your post to be honest - you want us to rate a player without reference to how he did when we saw him play?
Oh and agree with the general sentiment that Doncaster have embarrassed themselves on another thread here.
He has got you there.
Edit: to add we had vassell on loan a couple of years back. He was shit but he scored one good goal. Then he tore us to shreds for Blackpool last year. Based on that he was Cristiano Ronaldo but honestly I think it was more us than him.
More importantly it is an absolutely fantastic name.
Edit - two posts, and I still forgot what I came here for. Samir Carruthers in on loan, Joe Rothwell just confirmed to Blackburn.
Sad to lose Rothwell but not totally convinced he ever translated his talent into a really dominant run of...
We played them three times the year before, We will play them at least three times this year, we are at Home, and we are Oxford - we love our high horse. It is a shit draw.